top of page

Monday Briefing

Nov 2
4 min read

Updated: Nov 2

If You Have to See People

Working,You May Have a Management Problem

Working from home is back in the news.

New rules have recently taken effect for employees covered by Australia's Clerks Award, setting out arrangements for requesting and recording working-from-home arrangements.

Employers affected by the changes obviously need to understand their obligations.

But there is a larger management question underneath all this.

How do you know whether somebody is doing a good job when you can't see them doing it?

My answer is reasonably simple.

The same way you should know when they are sitting twenty metres away from you.

By being clear about what you expect, staying in communication and looking at what gets done.


Being at work is not the same as being productive

For generations, managers have taken some comfort from seeing people arrive in the morning and leave in the afternoon.

Everyone appeared busy.

But appearing busy and producing something worthwhile are not necessarily the same thing.

An employee can spend eight hours in an office attending unnecessary meetings, answering emails, dealing with interruptions and producing very little of lasting value.

Another might spend six uninterrupted hours working from home and accomplish considerably more.

The reverse can also be true.

Some people thrive away from the workplace. Others struggle with isolation, distraction or lack of structure.

That is why I think arguments about whether working from home is inherently good or bad miss the point.

The real issue is how the work is being managed.


Start with clarity

If I were managing someone working remotely, I would want both of us to be able to answer some basic questions.

  • What are you responsible for?

  • What needs to be achieved this week?

  • What does good performance look like?

  • When do I need to hear from you?

  • What decisions can you make yourself?

  • When should you ask for help?

If those questions cannot be answered clearly, bringing the employee back into the office probably won't solve the underlying problem.

They may simply become an unclear employee sitting closer to an unclear manager.

Good management starts with clarity.

It always has.


Trust matters — but so does accountability

There is sometimes a tendency to put trust and accountability at opposite ends of the argument.

I don't think they are.

Good people generally want to be trusted.

Good people also understand that if they are being paid to perform a role, they are accountable for doing it properly.

A manager shouldn't need to check whether someone is sitting at their computer every twenty minutes.

But neither should an employee disappear for three days and then complain about being micromanaged when somebody asks what is happening.

There needs to be a sensible middle ground.

Trust people with the work. Be clear about the result. Stay connected. Deal with problems when they arise.

That applies whether somebody works from home, from an office or from the other side of the country.


Don't wait too long when performance slips

This is where remote and flexible working can expose another weakness in management.

Managers sometimes avoid difficult conversations.

When everybody is together, poor performance may eventually become impossible to ignore.

When people work remotely, it can be easier to let concerns drift.

A deadline is missed.

Communication becomes patchy.

The quality of work declines.

Other team members quietly start carrying more of the load.

The manager notices but waits, hoping things will improve. Unfortunately, usually they don't.

Fair Work's own guidance on managing underperformance makes a straightforward point: regular conversations, clear goals, feedback and support are important, and underperformance should be addressed promptly and sensitively.

That is not complicated management theory.

It is good management.

And it is considerably fairer to the employee than allowing frustration to build for three months before suddenly announcing there is a serious performance problem.


Flexibility has to work both ways

There is another point worth remembering.

Flexible work cannot simply be about what suits the employer.

But neither can it be entirely about what suits the employee.

The organisation still has customers to serve, colleagues who depend on one another, deadlines to meet and work that has to be done.

The sensible question is:

Can we find an arrangement that works reasonably well for the person and the organisation?

Sometimes the answer will be yes.

Sometimes the nature of the work will make that difficult.

And sometimes different employees will legitimately have different arrangements because their jobs are different.

Managers need enough confidence to explain those differences rather than hiding behind a blanket rule simply because it is easier.


What I would do Monday morning

Rather than starting another debate about how many days people should spend in the office, I would ask managers to look at their own teams.

Pick each role and ask:

Could I describe, in plain English, what good performance in this job looks like?

  • Not how many hours the person sits at a desk.

  • Not whether their green light is showing on Teams.

  • Not how quickly they answer an email.

What are the results that tell you this person is doing a good job?

If you cannot answer that question, work on it with the employee.

Because this issue extends well beyond working from home.

It is about something much more fundamental.

People perform better when they know what is expected of them, have reasonable freedom to get on with it, receive feedback along the way and know they will be held accountable for the result.

That was true long before anybody had heard of hybrid work.

And I suspect it will remain true long after we stop arguing about it.


— Michael A. CassarExecutive Perspective | It’s Achievable®


 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Explore Further:

stay connected

with

Momentum Matters
Executive perspective→

Practical books, frameworks and resources for lkeadership, change and Personal growth.

 

​

Ideas and observations for leaders navigating change , uncertainty and important decisions.

About Michael→

More about my background, experience and approach. 

general enquiries

Occasional reflections on change, resilience, personal growth,leadership and moving forward through life's different stages.

© 2023 by It’s Achievable®.

All rights reserved.

PO Box 200, Dendy Plaza. Brighton Vic Aust. 3186

admin@miancagroup.com

​

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
bottom of page